feat(release): 建批时冻结 + 验收通过自动批准 —— 把"每份文档 8 步"砍掉两步并去掉两次卡死

背景:发布管理把"逐条核验"的仪式强加给每一份文档。实测一份文档要 9~11 次交互,
且有两处顺序陷阱(冻结后批准 → 建批 422;生成即固化 → 批准被永久钉住)。

P0-1 建批时冻结:
- CreateReleaseBatch 在未指定版本时,自己把当前实时计划冻结成一份**已确认**版本并绑定
  (同一事务;同摘要复用最近版本,planned 或 confirmed 都可复用,因此同一份计划不堆版本)。
- 语义不变:批一旦建立,清单/摘要/验收轮次/目标库绑定全部不可变、回滚按它走;变的只是
  "谁在什么时候按固化键"——从操作员的手动两步变成建批这一下。
- 效果:去掉「生成新版本」「确认冻结」两步;消灭"批准晚于冻结 → 422"这类顺序陷阱;
  前端不再传版本 id,也不再有"所选知识不在冻结清单里"的阻断。
- 计划→清单项的映射抽成 ChangeSetItemsFromPlan 供两处共用,否则两处算出的摘要不同,
  "同一计划复用同一版本"永远不命中。

P0-2 验收通过自动批准:
- 验收三项结论达发布门槛(knowledge_exists/chunks_present=passed,retrieval_hit 与门槛同
  口径)时,由 worker 写入 reviewer_ref='system:auto' 的批准记录,替代"每份文档点一次批准"。
- 策略 TEST_AUTO_REVIEW_POLICY = off | internal(默认,仅对内)| all;值不认识拒绝启动。
  只影响审核这一步:生产授权、双闸与发布前快照门禁不受影响。界面上只读展示当前策略。
- 安全边界(写死在审核 SQL 里):系统只允许写"第一条"审核——人工一旦表过态,机器不得用一条
  更晚的 approved 把人工结论翻回去;人工随时可再审。集成测试去掉该约束即 FAIL(已实测)。
- 自动批准自身的任何失败都不影响验收结论,只上报。

顺带(P1-1 前半,已被 P0-1 取代的部分已删除):
- 写操作失败把服务端 {"error": ...} 的原因带出来,并对已知原因给出下一步(不再只给 HTTP 状态码)。
- 当前的"不在已冻结清单里"标注与就地修复按钮随 P0-1 一起移除(该失败模式已不存在)。

测试:bind_time_freeze_integration_test.go(绑定已确认版本/同计划复用/冻结后不可变/
动作不符仍 NotEligible)、auto_review_integration_test.go(系统只写第一条、人工可再审)、
validate_test.go(对内自动/对外不自动/策略关闭/验收未过不批/自身失败不影响验收)、
auto_review_test.go、config_test 及前端能力解析测试。
实测耗时:本机 Go 全量 26 包通过、前端 178 条通过。
This commit is contained in:
姚章浩
2026-10-10 15:05:20 +08:00
parent 32450a7c7b
commit acf053faf3
21 changed files with 630 additions and 44 deletions
+55 -7
View File
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@ import (
"encoding/hex"
"encoding/json"
"errors"
"fmt"
"time"
"knowledge-governance/internal/governance"
@@ -23,6 +24,9 @@ var (
type ValidateStore interface {
LoadPublicationForValidation(context.Context, string) (postgresstore.PublicationForValidation, error)
AppendAcceptanceResult(context.Context, governance.AcceptanceResult) error
// ReviewPublication 复用人工审核同一条写入路径:同一套合法性校验与"最新验收轮次"绑定,
// 自动批准不另开一条 SQL,避免两套口径。
ReviewPublication(context.Context, governance.ReviewPublicationRequest) (governance.PublicationReview, error)
}
type ValidateClient interface {
@@ -35,17 +39,26 @@ type ValidateHandlerConfig struct {
Client ValidateClient
RunID string
PolicyVersion string
Now func() time.Time
// AutoReviewPolicy:验收通过后是否由系统写入批准。零值按"仅对内"处理(与 env 默认一致)。
AutoReviewPolicy governance.AutoReviewPolicy
// Report 只用于记录自动批准自身的失败:它绝不能把验收判成失败。
Report func(error)
Now func() time.Time
}
type ValidateHandler struct {
store ValidateStore
client ValidateClient
runID string
policyVersion string
now func() time.Time
store ValidateStore
client ValidateClient
runID string
policyVersion string
autoReviewPolicy governance.AutoReviewPolicy
report func(error)
now func() time.Time
}
// autoReviewerRef:自动批准在审计里必须一眼可辨,绝不冒用某个人的身份。
const autoReviewerRef = "system:auto"
type validatePayload struct {
PublicationID string `json:"publication_id"`
}
@@ -60,9 +73,16 @@ func NewValidateHandler(config ValidateHandlerConfig) (*ValidateHandler, error)
if config.Now == nil {
config.Now = time.Now
}
if config.AutoReviewPolicy == "" {
config.AutoReviewPolicy = governance.AutoReviewInternal
}
if config.Report == nil {
config.Report = func(error) {}
}
return &ValidateHandler{
store: config.Store, client: config.Client, runID: config.RunID,
policyVersion: config.PolicyVersion, now: config.Now,
policyVersion: config.PolicyVersion, autoReviewPolicy: config.AutoReviewPolicy,
report: config.Report, now: config.Now,
}, nil
}
@@ -104,9 +124,37 @@ func (handler *ValidateHandler) Handle(ctx context.Context, job jobs.Job) error
if err := handler.append(ctx, publication.ID, runID, "retrieval_hit", governance.AcceptanceManualRequired, json.RawMessage(`{"reason":"thresholds_unresolved"}`), now); err != nil {
return err
}
handler.autoApprove(ctx, publication, runID, knowledgeState, chunksState, now)
return nil
}
// autoApprove:验收通过的知识由系统写入批准,替代"每份文档点一次批准"。
//
// 触发条件与发布门槛同口径:knowledge_exists / chunks_present 必须 passed
// (retrieval_hit 固定为 manual_required,发布门槛同样接受)。
// 自动批准自身的任何失败都不影响验收结论——只上报,不返回错误。
func (handler *ValidateHandler) autoApprove(ctx context.Context, publication postgresstore.PublicationForValidation, runID string, knowledgeState, chunksState governance.AcceptanceState, now time.Time) {
if !handler.autoReviewPolicy.Allows(publication.TargetScope) {
return
}
if knowledgeState != governance.AcceptancePassed || chunksState != governance.AcceptancePassed {
return
}
_, err := handler.store.ReviewPublication(ctx, governance.ReviewPublicationRequest{
PublicationID: publication.ID,
Decision: governance.ReviewApproved,
DecidedVisibility: governance.Visibility(publication.TargetScope),
ReviewerRef: autoReviewerRef,
DecisionCode: "approved_for_release",
Now: now,
})
if err == nil || errors.Is(err, postgresstore.ErrPublicationReviewNotEligible) {
// 已经有人审过(或不满足审核前置):不覆盖人工结论。
return
}
handler.report(fmt.Errorf("auto review %s: %w", publication.ID, err))
}
func (handler *ValidateHandler) append(ctx context.Context, publicationID, runID, checkType string, state governance.AcceptanceState, evidence json.RawMessage, observedAt time.Time) error {
result := governance.AcceptanceResult{
ID: acceptanceResultID(publicationID, runID, checkType),
@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@ package testweknora
import (
"context"
"errors"
"testing"
"time"
@@ -89,6 +90,8 @@ func TestValidateHandlerFailsChecksWithoutAborting(t *testing.T) {
type validateStoreStub struct {
publication postgresstore.PublicationForValidation
appended []governance.AcceptanceResult
reviews []governance.ReviewPublicationRequest
reviewErr error
}
func (store *validateStoreStub) LoadPublicationForValidation(context.Context, string) (postgresstore.PublicationForValidation, error) {
@@ -100,6 +103,14 @@ func (store *validateStoreStub) AppendAcceptanceResult(_ context.Context, result
return nil
}
func (store *validateStoreStub) ReviewPublication(_ context.Context, request governance.ReviewPublicationRequest) (governance.PublicationReview, error) {
if store.reviewErr != nil {
return governance.PublicationReview{}, store.reviewErr
}
store.reviews = append(store.reviews, request)
return governance.PublicationReview{ID: "rv-auto", PublicationID: request.PublicationID}, nil
}
type validateClientStub struct {
knowledge weknora.Knowledge
chunkTotal int64
@@ -116,3 +127,85 @@ func (client *validateClientStub) ListChunks(context.Context, string, int, int,
}
return chunks, client.chunkTotal, nil
}
// 自动批准:验收通过的知识由系统写入批准,替代"每份文档人工点一次批准"。
// 关键边界:对外不自动、策略可关、验收没过不批、自动批准自己失败也绝不把验收判成失败。
func TestValidateHandlerAutoApprovesVerifiedInternalPublications(t *testing.T) {
run := func(t *testing.T, scope string, policy governance.AutoReviewPolicy, knowledgeBase, knowledgeID string, reviewErr error) (*validateStoreStub, error) {
t.Helper()
client := &validateClientStub{
knowledge: weknora.Knowledge{ID: knowledgeID, KnowledgeBaseID: knowledgeBase},
chunkTotal: 3,
}
store := &validateStoreStub{
publication: postgresstore.PublicationForValidation{ID: "publication-1", TestKBID: "kb-1", KnowledgeID: "knowledge-1", TargetScope: scope},
reviewErr: reviewErr,
}
now := time.Date(2026, time.October, 10, 8, 0, 0, 0, time.UTC)
handler, err := NewValidateHandler(ValidateHandlerConfig{
Store: store, Client: client, RunID: "run-1", PolicyVersion: "structural-v1",
AutoReviewPolicy: policy, Now: func() time.Time { return now },
})
if err != nil {
t.Fatal(err)
}
return store, handler.Handle(context.Background(), jobs.Job{ID: "job-1", Payload: []byte(`{"publication_id":"publication-1"}`)})
}
store, err := run(t, "internal", governance.AutoReviewInternal, "kb-1", "knowledge-1", nil)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("Handle() error = %v", err)
}
if len(store.reviews) != 1 {
t.Fatalf("auto reviews = %d, want 1", len(store.reviews))
}
review := store.reviews[0]
if review.ReviewerRef != "system:auto" || review.Decision != governance.ReviewApproved || review.DecidedVisibility != governance.VisibilityInternal || review.DecisionCode != "approved_for_release" {
t.Fatalf("auto review = %#v", review)
}
if review.Now.IsZero() {
t.Fatalf("auto review must carry the observation time")
}
// 对外:默认不自动批准。
external, err := run(t, "external", governance.AutoReviewInternal, "kb-1", "knowledge-1", nil)
if err != nil || len(external.reviews) != 0 {
t.Fatalf("external auto reviews = %d error = %v", len(external.reviews), err)
}
// 策略关闭。
off, err := run(t, "internal", governance.AutoReviewOff, "kb-1", "knowledge-1", nil)
if err != nil || len(off.reviews) != 0 {
t.Fatalf("off auto reviews = %d error = %v", len(off.reviews), err)
}
// 验收没过(知识存在性校验失败):不批准。
failed, err := run(t, "internal", governance.AutoReviewInternal, "kb-other", "knowledge-1", nil)
if err != nil || len(failed.reviews) != 0 {
t.Fatalf("failed-acceptance auto reviews = %d error = %v", len(failed.reviews), err)
}
// 自动批准自己失败(例如已被人工审过)不能让验收失败。
conflicted, err := run(t, "internal", governance.AutoReviewInternal, "kb-1", "knowledge-1", postgresstore.ErrPublicationReviewNotEligible)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("review-not-eligible must not fail validation: %v", err)
}
if len(conflicted.reviews) != 0 || len(conflicted.appended) != 3 {
t.Fatalf("conflicted reviews = %d appended = %d", len(conflicted.reviews), len(conflicted.appended))
}
// 其他错误也只是上报,不影响验收结论。
reported := 0
client := &validateClientStub{knowledge: weknora.Knowledge{ID: "knowledge-1", KnowledgeBaseID: "kb-1"}, chunkTotal: 3}
store2 := &validateStoreStub{publication: postgresstore.PublicationForValidation{ID: "publication-1", TestKBID: "kb-1", KnowledgeID: "knowledge-1", TargetScope: "internal"}, reviewErr: errors.New("boom")}
handler, err := NewValidateHandler(ValidateHandlerConfig{
Store: store2, Client: client, RunID: "run-1", PolicyVersion: "structural-v1",
AutoReviewPolicy: governance.AutoReviewInternal, Report: func(error) { reported++ },
Now: func() time.Time { return time.Now().UTC() },
})
if err != nil {
t.Fatal(err)
}
if err := handler.Handle(context.Background(), jobs.Job{ID: "job-2", Payload: []byte(`{"publication_id":"publication-1"}`)}); err != nil {
t.Fatalf("auto review failure must not fail validation: %v", err)
}
if reported != 1 {
t.Fatalf("reported = %d, want 1", reported)
}
}