Files
Enterprise-Knowledge-Base/cli/acceptance/contract/errorcodes_test.go
T
nullkey 8bcbf5a154 refactor(cli): align command surface with mainstream conventions
Empirical mainstream-CLI surveys (gh / kubectl / aws / gcloud / stripe /
flyctl / terraform / vercel / netlify / lark) drove five alignment
fixes — each replaces a weknora-only design choice that mainstream CLIs
do not share. No backwards-compat shims; the CLI has no v0.1 users yet.

1. Single --kb flag (was --kb-id + --kb mutually exclusive)

   Survey: 0/7 mainstream CLIs use two parallel flags for "by id" vs
   "by name". Single flag (gh -R, gcloud --project) or positional
   (kubectl, stripe, terraform). Closest analog — gcloud --project —
   collapses identifier types onto one flag.

   Now: every command exposes one --kb flag; client-side prefix
   detection (cmdutil.IsKBID looks for "kb_") routes id-form values
   through directly and name-form values through ListKnowledgeBases.
   Mirrors gcloud --project's id-or-name auto-detection.

   Touched: search, chat, doc list / upload / delete, link.
   Factory.ResolveKB chain trimmed from 5 levels to 4.

2. link supersedes init

   Survey: only vercel and netlify ship both `init` AND `link` as
   siblings, and they keep them semantically distinct. weknora's pair
   wrote the same .weknora/project.yaml file with the same meaning,
   differentiated only by interactivity — that's a flag concern, not
   a command concern.

   Now: cmd/init/ deleted. cmd/link absorbs the interactive flow:
     - link --kb <id-or-name>  → non-interactive write
     - link on a TTY            → interactive prompt (lists KBs)
     - link non-TTY without --kb → CodeKBIDRequired
   Always overwrites silently (matches vercel link / netlify link /
   kubectl apply rather than git init's refuse-if-exists).

   Dead code purged: --force flag, CodeProjectAlreadyLinked error code.

3. whoami dropped

   Survey: 7/7 mainstream CLIs ship exactly one identity command —
   never both a status and a whoami. gh / gcloud / stripe pick status
   (config + live API); aws / kubectl / flyctl pick whoami (live API).

   weknora's auth status was already a superset of whoami (host +
   context + user + email + tenant_id + tenant_name vs user_id +
   tenant_id), so dropping whoami preserves all functionality and
   aligns with the gh / gcloud / stripe form.

4. kb get alias dropped

   `view` was already primary (gh repo view / gh pr view convention);
   `get` was kept as a cobra alias for v0.0/v0.1 callers. With no
   v0.0/v0.1 users to break, the alias is just noise on the command
   surface. Acceptance contract envelope cases renamed kb_get.* →
   kb_view.*; goldens renamed in lockstep.

5. api refactored to gh shape (-X/--method, default GET, auto-POST)

   gh CLI's signature is `gh api <endpoint> [--method M]` — single
   positional path, method as a flag, default GET, auto-promoted to
   POST when a body is supplied. weknora's previous `api <method>
   <path>` inverted this and forced the method to be passed even for
   GET — a needless deviation from our declared north star.

   Now: `api <path> [-X METHOD] [--data ...]`. Exit-10 protocol
   on the DELETE escape-hatch is preserved; -X DELETE still hits
   ConfirmDestructive when -y absent.

Plus: AGENTS.md gains an explicit note that `doctor` is a deliberate
divergence from gh / lark — borrowed from `flutter doctor` / `brew
doctor` because RAG deployments routinely break on misconfigured
embeddings / storage / credentials and a 4-status structured envelope
is the cleanest surface for it.

Tests: 24 cli packages green (was 26 in PR-14; init + whoami packages
removed). Acceptance contract envelope cases for whoami removed,
kb_get → kb_view renamed, search args / mock path updated for the
kb_<id> form. e2e harness flag args updated. Factory.ResolveKB tests
rewritten for the single-flag shape. api_test driver updated for the
positional-path / -X-method shape.
2026-05-12 13:20:42 +08:00

206 lines
6.6 KiB
Go

// cli/acceptance/contract/errorcodes_test.go
package contract_test
import (
"go/ast"
"go/parser"
"go/token"
"os"
"path/filepath"
"strings"
"testing"
"github.com/Tencent/WeKnora/cli/internal/cmdutil"
)
// TestAllReferencedCodesAreRegistered scans cli/cmd/ for every literal use of
// cmdutil.NewError(codeXxx, ...) and cmdutil.Wrapf(codeXxx, ...) and verifies
// that codeXxx is registered in cmdutil.AllCodes().
//
// ClassifyHTTPError is dynamic: callers pass cmdutil.ClassifyHTTPError(err)
// as the first arg. We bridge that via cmdutil.ClassifyHTTPErrorOutputs(),
// which returns every code that the switch can return — those are added to
// the registered set so the AST scanner doesn't false-positive on them.
//
// Limitations (documented in spec §4.3):
// - Only literal cmdutil.CodeXxx idents are detected; codes assigned to
// a local variable then passed are NOT scanned (rare pattern).
// - cmdutil.ClassifyHTTPError(...) call expressions are skipped — bridge
// covers them.
// - v0.x does not enforce a baseline diff (spec ADR-6b); v0.9 will.
func TestAllReferencedCodesAreRegistered(t *testing.T) {
registered := make(map[cmdutil.ErrorCode]struct{})
for _, c := range cmdutil.AllCodes() {
registered[c] = struct{}{}
}
// Bridge: ClassifyHTTPError returns these dynamically; treat them as
// "registered" for the purposes of the AST scan since callers pass the
// function call (not a literal ident) as arg0.
for _, c := range cmdutil.ClassifyHTTPErrorOutputs() {
registered[c] = struct{}{}
}
referenced := scanCmdDir(t, "../../cmd")
for code, locs := range referenced {
if _, ok := registered[code]; !ok {
for _, loc := range locs {
t.Errorf("%s: error code %q referenced but not registered in cmdutil.AllCodes()", loc, code)
}
}
}
}
// scanCmdDir walks cli/cmd/** for *.go files (excluding tests) and collects
// every literal cmdutil.CodeXxx ident passed as the first arg to
// cmdutil.NewError / cmdutil.Wrapf.
//
// Returns map keyed by ErrorCode value (the const's underlying string), with
// a slice of source positions for nicer error messages.
func scanCmdDir(t *testing.T, dir string) map[cmdutil.ErrorCode][]token.Position {
t.Helper()
out := make(map[cmdutil.ErrorCode][]token.Position)
fset := token.NewFileSet()
walkAndScan(t, fset, dir, out)
return out
}
func walkAndScan(t *testing.T, fset *token.FileSet, root string, out map[cmdutil.ErrorCode][]token.Position) {
t.Helper()
err := filepath.Walk(root, func(path string, info os.FileInfo, err error) error {
if err != nil {
return err
}
if info.IsDir() {
return nil
}
if filepath.Ext(path) != ".go" {
return nil
}
if strings.HasSuffix(path, "_test.go") {
return nil
}
f, err := parser.ParseFile(fset, path, nil, 0)
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("parse %s: %v", path, err)
}
collectErrorCodes(fset, f, out)
return nil
})
if err != nil {
t.Fatalf("walk %s: %v", root, err)
}
}
func collectErrorCodes(fset *token.FileSet, f *ast.File, out map[cmdutil.ErrorCode][]token.Position) {
ast.Inspect(f, func(n ast.Node) bool {
call, ok := n.(*ast.CallExpr)
if !ok || len(call.Args) == 0 {
return true
}
sel, ok := call.Fun.(*ast.SelectorExpr)
if !ok {
return true
}
x, ok := sel.X.(*ast.Ident)
if !ok || x.Name != "cmdutil" {
return true
}
if sel.Sel.Name != "NewError" && sel.Sel.Name != "Wrapf" {
return true
}
// First arg should be cmdutil.CodeXxx (SelectorExpr ident).
// If it's a function call (e.g. cmdutil.ClassifyHTTPError(err)), skip
// — bridge handles those.
arg0Sel, ok := call.Args[0].(*ast.SelectorExpr)
if !ok {
return true
}
argX, ok := arg0Sel.X.(*ast.Ident)
if !ok || argX.Name != "cmdutil" {
return true
}
code, ok := identToErrorCode(arg0Sel.Sel.Name)
if !ok {
// Unknown ident name — record as bogus so the test fails with
// a clear "code referenced but not registered" message.
code = cmdutil.ErrorCode("UNKNOWN_REF:" + arg0Sel.Sel.Name)
}
pos := fset.Position(call.Pos())
out[code] = append(out[code], pos)
return true
})
}
// identToErrorCode maps an ident name like "CodeAuthUnauthenticated" to its
// underlying ErrorCode value via a simple switch. Avoids reflect.
// Keep in sync with cmdutil.AllCodes() — adding a new const here is the same
// bookkeeping as adding it to AllCodes().
func identToErrorCode(name string) (cmdutil.ErrorCode, bool) {
switch name {
case "CodeAuthUnauthenticated":
return cmdutil.CodeAuthUnauthenticated, true
case "CodeAuthTokenExpired":
return cmdutil.CodeAuthTokenExpired, true
case "CodeAuthBadCredential":
return cmdutil.CodeAuthBadCredential, true
case "CodeAuthForbidden":
return cmdutil.CodeAuthForbidden, true
case "CodeAuthCrossTenantBlocked":
return cmdutil.CodeAuthCrossTenantBlocked, true
case "CodeAuthTenantMismatch":
return cmdutil.CodeAuthTenantMismatch, true
case "CodeResourceNotFound":
return cmdutil.CodeResourceNotFound, true
case "CodeResourceAlreadyExists":
return cmdutil.CodeResourceAlreadyExists, true
case "CodeResourceLocked":
return cmdutil.CodeResourceLocked, true
case "CodeInputInvalidArgument":
return cmdutil.CodeInputInvalidArgument, true
case "CodeInputMissingFlag":
return cmdutil.CodeInputMissingFlag, true
case "CodeServerError":
return cmdutil.CodeServerError, true
case "CodeServerTimeout":
return cmdutil.CodeServerTimeout, true
case "CodeServerRateLimited":
return cmdutil.CodeServerRateLimited, true
case "CodeServerIncompatibleVersion":
return cmdutil.CodeServerIncompatibleVersion, true
case "CodeNetworkError":
return cmdutil.CodeNetworkError, true
case "CodeLocalConfigCorrupt":
return cmdutil.CodeLocalConfigCorrupt, true
case "CodeLocalKeychainDenied":
return cmdutil.CodeLocalKeychainDenied, true
case "CodeLocalFileIO":
return cmdutil.CodeLocalFileIO, true
case "CodeLocalUnimplemented":
return cmdutil.CodeLocalUnimplemented, true
case "CodeLocalContextNotFound":
return cmdutil.CodeLocalContextNotFound, true
case "CodeKBIDRequired":
return cmdutil.CodeKBIDRequired, true
case "CodeKBNotFound":
return cmdutil.CodeKBNotFound, true
case "CodeProjectLinkCorrupt":
return cmdutil.CodeProjectLinkCorrupt, true
case "CodeUserAborted":
return cmdutil.CodeUserAborted, true
case "CodeUploadFileNotFound":
return cmdutil.CodeUploadFileNotFound, true
case "CodeSSEStreamAborted":
return cmdutil.CodeSSEStreamAborted, true
case "CodeSessionCreateFailed":
return cmdutil.CodeSessionCreateFailed, true
case "CodeMCPReadonlyMode":
return cmdutil.CodeMCPReadonlyMode, true
case "CodeMCPToolNotAllowed":
return cmdutil.CodeMCPToolNotAllowed, true
case "CodeMCPSchemaUnknown":
return cmdutil.CodeMCPSchemaUnknown, true
}
return "", false
}